Performance comparison between steam injected gas turbine and combined cycle during frequency drops saeed bahrami 1, ali ghaffari 1, magnus genrup 2 and marcus thern 2, 1 department of mechanical engineering, k. What is the difference between gas turbine and gas engine in gas power plant answer harish devrani in gas turbine energy conversion or we can say generation takes place outside the unit whereas in case of gas engine energy generation takes place within the unit. What is the difference between a gas turbine, a steam. The temperature difference between the exhaust gas and. The fuel most suitable for gas turbine propulsion is natural gas. Sep 23, 2007 a gas turbine, also called a combustion turbine, is a rotary engine that extracts energy from a flow of hot gas produced by combustion of gas or fuel oil in a stream of compressed air. Wight to power ratio is high in steam turbine than gas turbine. The first question faced by the design engineer is which standard steam turbine as to be selected either api 611 or api 612. In the present work, a comparison between mcfcgas turbine and mcfcsteam turbine is conducted in order to evaluate the main advantages and disadvantages in adopting one solution instead of the. Gas turbines can deliver either torque or thrust as the work output, while steam turbines almost all the time delivers torque as the work output. Performance comparison between steam injected gas turbine. Experimental study on comparison of cooling effectiveness. Impact of size on cost for gas turbinecombined cycle 24 impact of size on cost for wind farms 27 iii. Combined heat and power technology fact sheets series.
Difference between closed cycle gas turbine and open cycle. Turbines, in general, convert either thermal or kinetic energy of the fluid into work. So you need to look at the cycles for steam and gas turbines i suspect that is where the diagrams come in and they want you to discuss the differences between the steam cycle and the gas turbine cycle. Gas turbine vs steam turbine industrial professionals. Those 11 criterias are cycle of operation, working fuel used, type of fuel used, manner of heat input, quality of heat input, efficiency, part load efficiency, turbine blade life of a turbine, control on power production and cost of turbine plant installation compared in below table. Comparison between mcfcgas turbine and mcfcsteam turbine. Comparing combined gas tubrinesteam turbine and marine low speed piston enginesteam turbine systems in naval applications abstract the article compares combined systems in naval applications. A gas turbine power plant can achieve 100mw output by installing 2x50mw units, which will install with a more compact foot print at subsequently reduced civil works cost. Mechanical engineering channel anuniverse 22 has started to stand on the shoulders of engineering giants and now, it is a place to hang out to learn the basics of mechanical engineering. In orc, water is replaced with a high molecular mass fluid with lower degree of boiling temperature in comparison with water. What is the difference between gas turbine and gas engine. Performance and cost evaluation of organic rankine cycle.
Jun 16, 2016 the difference between gas turbine and steam turbine can be done on the basis of components, space for installation, mass per kw produced, installation and running cost efficiency, control with the changing load condition, starting, efficiency and dependency on water supply. However the gas turbine work also has to power the air compressor which work is then unavailable to output. One of the advantages of the closed turbine gas cycle is that the turbine stays clean because the combustion products do not pass through it. In this post, we will see the difference between api 611 and api 612. The difference between steam and gas turbines kraftwerk forschung. Results obtained show that both these configurations allow to obtain high conversion efficiencies and reduced emissions. Whats the difference between a gas turbine and a steam. The object of the analysis is the combined gas turbinesteam turbine system which is compared to the combined marine lowspeed diesel enginesteam. Combustion engine power plants comprised of multiple generating units complement renewable energy without sacrificing efficiency.
Aug 04, 2012 steam turbine uses high pressure steam as the working fluid, while the gas turbine uses air or some other gas as the working fluid. Steam turbine governing systems and electronic governor retrofit 159 process is required at a specific pressure below the inlet pressure. In its simplest form, a steam turbine consist of a boiler steam generator, turbine, condenser, feed pump and a variety of auxiliary devices. For this reason the blades are cooled with air that flows out of small openings and creates a protective film between the exhaust gases and the blades. Unlike with reciprocating engines, for instance, compression, heating and.
Performance comparison between steam injected gas turbine and combined cycle during frequency drops. The turbine is a type of engine, which might be thought of as a more efficient choice than a gas engine or. Micro gas turbine an overview sciencedirect topics. Ger3705 ge steam turbine design philosophy and technology. Difference between gas turbine and steam turbine compare. May 06, 2017 however the gas turbine work also has to power the air compressor which work is then unavailable to output. Difference between gas turbine and steam turbine in tabular form. Steam turbine is basically an expander delivering torque as the work output, while a gas turbine is a combined device of compressor, combustion chamber, and turbine executing a cyclic operation to deliver. Valentini gas turbine power plants 9 mass flow rates and so this plant can be adopted on sites with low water availability. Difference between steam engine and steam turbine compare. Comparison between natural gas and diesel fuel oil onboard. Oct 05, 2019 idea of gas turbine is very old one,its working principle is an advanced version of wind mill.
Comparing combined gas tubrinesteam turbine and marine low. A gas turbine power plant can achieve 100mw output by installing 2x50mw units, which will install with a more compact foot print at subsequently reduced. The object of the analysis is the combined gas turbine steam turbine system which is compared to the combined marine lowspeed diesel engine steam turbine system. To achieve efficient working of turbine,the movement of gas is controlled and directed to blades. Stag combinedcycle systems are designated with a code system to capture key system parameters. Pdf performance comparison between steam injected gas. The difference between steam and gas turbines kraftwerk.
Schofield ge company schenectady, ny introduction the need to provide stateoftheart products for a diverse and everchanging market is the chal lenge facing steam turbinegenerator manufactur ers in the 90s. Two gassteam combined cycles using thermodynamic analysis are. While selecting a steam turbine as a driver for compressors or pumps for refinerypetrochemical industries. Steam turbines therefore do not come into contact with the fuel deployed and work at temperatures between 500 and 650 c. This will give a clear view of the modifications, if any, that needs to be made to a gas turbine to accommodate this gas fuel efficiently under the marine design conditions. However it takes time for startup in which it it takes hour in the other hand gas turbine approximately 30 minutes for normal operating speed and also gas turbine is easier to maintain.
Performance comparison between steam injected gas turbine and. A 500 kw steam turbine utilizing a natural gas fired boiler will have estimated nox emissions in the range of 2681 ppm at 3% oxygen. The basic difference between gas turbine and steam turbine is that gas turbine is easy to start and control easily while steam turbine is difficult to start and difficult to control. Comparison between closed cycle gas turbine and open cycle gas turbine can be done in 11 different criterias. Sep 15, 2006 steam turbine uses high pressure steam as the working fluid, while the gas turbine uses air or some other gas as the working fluid. What is the differences between gas turbine and a steam. Difference between gas turbine and steam turbine mechanical. Difference between condensing turbine and back pressure. Comparison between two gas turbine solutions to increase. Steam turbine is basically an expander delivering torque as the work output, while a gas turbine is a combined device of compressor, combustion chamber, and turbine executing a cyclic operation to deliver work as either torque. Technical and economical feasibility of the rankine compression. It is also selected when no high pressure steam is available. A steam turbine is a mechanical device that extracts thermal energy from pressurized steam, and converts it into useful mechanical work. Pdf study the performance of the combined gas turbinesteam.
The aircraft engine book, rolls royce uk the basic gas turbine cycle is illustrated pv and ts diagrams in figure 5. Comparison of combined heat and power generation plants. Also it will give a prediction for the thermodynamic. Understanding and preventing steam turbine overspeeds by william e. Idea of gas turbine is very old one,its working principle is an advanced version of wind mill. In the present work, a comparison between mcfcgas turbine and mcfcsteam turbine is conducted in order to evaluate the main advantages and disadvantages in adopting one solution instead of the other one. The difference between gas turbine and steam turbine can be done on the basis of components, space for installation, mass per kw produced, installation and running cost efficiency, control with the changing load condition, starting, efficiency and dependency on water supply. In general, a steam turbine is a rotary heat engine that converts thermal energy contained in the steam to mechanical energy or to electrical energy. The object of the analysis is the combined gas turbinesteam turbine system which is compared to the combined marine lowspeed diesel enginesteam turbine system. Effect of size on cost of gas turbine combined cycle units 10 2. There is a type of gas turbine called an ultramicroturbine that is even smaller than the micro gas turbine.
The difference between gas turbine and steam turbine can be done on the basis of components, space for installation, mass per kw produced, installation and running cost efficiency, control with the changing load condition, starting, efficiency and. The reheat gas turbinesteam turbine combined cycle is better as compared to the. Comparison between closed cycle gas turbine and open cycle. These ultramicro gas turbines are still in the research stage of their development but they offer intriguing possibilities. With temperatures up to 1500 c, these gases are much hotter than those in steam turbines. Two gas steam combined cycles using thermodynamic analysis are. Those 11 criterias are cycle of operation, working fuel used, type of fuel used, manner of heat input, quality of heat input, efficiency, part load efficiency, turbine blade life of a turbine, control on power production and cost of turbine plant installation compared in. Velocity and pressure compounding of steam turbines. Comparison between natural gas and diesel fuel oil onboard 111 results with the original diesel case. What is the difference between a gas turbine and a steam. A ccgt can produce up to 50% more electricity from the same volume of fuel compared to a single gas turbine by simply using the waste heat in a steam turbine. Orc or organic rankine cycle basically resembles the steam cycle according to working principles. The basic difference between them is the circulation of working fluid.
Jun 08, 2016 the difference between closed cycle gas turbine and open cycle gas turbine can be done on the basis of source of heating, types of working fluid, circulation of air, wearing capacity of turbine blades, installation, maintenance cost and much more. A comparison can be drawn between the gas turbines operating principle and a car engines. The differences between them is the medium used to run the turbine and that the gas turbine includes also a compressor which forces large amounts. The comparison refers to the additional power and efficiency increase resulting from the use of the heat in the exhaust gas leaving the piston engine or the gas turbine. He retired fro m amoco oil company, after more than 36 years in. Combustion engine vs gas turbine advantages of modularity. The performance characteristics of a gas turbine engine or gas turbine generator package gtg depends upon the type and model of engine being examined, the location at which it will be installed, the ambient conditions under which it will.
The difference between closed cycle gas turbine and open cycle gas turbine can be done on the basis of source of heating, types of working fluid, circulation of air, wearing capacity of turbine blades, installation, maintenance cost and much more. Whats the difference between steam turbine and gas. While, steam engine and steam turbine use the large latent heat of vaporization of steam for the power, the main difference is the maximum revolution per minute of the power cycles that both could provide. In the present work, a comparison between mcfc gas turbine and mcfc steam turbine is conducted in order to evaluate the main advantages and disadvantages in adopting one solution instead of the other one. Combined gas and steam turbine as prime mover in marine. May 12, 2008 results obtained show that both these configurations allow to obtain high conversion efficiencies and reduced emissions. What is steam turbine description and characteristics. Jul 24, 2016 comparison between closed cycle gas turbine and open cycle gas turbine can be done in 11 different criterias. In this article, we will see the difference between difference between condensing turbine and back pressure turbine. There are two basic types of turbines according to the mode of steam. A comparison can be drawn between the gas turbines.
Cost indexes for 316 stainless steel, nickel, and chrome 19. Turbine is a class of turbo machinery used to convert the energy in a flowing fluid into mechanical energy by the use of rotor mechanisms. Gas turbines on the other hand rotate directly in the hot combustion gases. The first steam turbine used for power generation was invented in 1884. The efficiency of the gas turbines is much higher than the steam turbine due to higher operating temperatures of the gas turbines. Condensing turbine is selected when the steam demand for the process drivers is greater than the lowpressure process steam requirements. Steam turbines are one of the most versatile and oldest prime mover technologies still in general production used to drive a generator or mechanical machinery. The air which is under pressure supplied to the turbine by the air compressor. Steam turbine uses high pressure steam as the working fluid, while the gas turbine uses air or some other gas as the working fluid.
In a gas turbine the working fluid remain in the same phase through out,but in steam turbine the working fluid changes its phase. Jun 04, 2018 in this article, we will see the difference between difference between condensing turbine and back pressure turbine. Nelson turbomachinery consultant dickinson, texas and perryc. What i know about steam turbine is more efficient than gas turbine and could provide more power than gas turbine and its efficiency is double the gas turbine. Steam and gas turbines, although they work under the same principle, they have different structures. Singleshaft gas turbines are more popular in the power generation industry due to their simplicity, lower price, and better energy recovery from. In both the noncondensing and condensing type units, a single or double controlled extraction may be considered, depending on the number of openings that steam exits the turbine prior to the exhaust figure 6. Jul 23, 20 in a gas turbine the working fluid remain in the same phase through out,but in steam turbine the working fluid changes its phase. Request pdf comparison between two gas turbine solutions to. Turbines a turbine is a rotary engine that exerts energy from a fluid flow and converts it into useful work. In the present work, a comparison between mcfc gas turbine and mcfc steam turbine is conducted in order to evaluate the main advantages and disadvantages in adopting one solution instead of the. Toosi university of technology, pardis street, vanak square, tehran 19991 43344, iran. Steam turbine is basically an expander delivering torque as the work output, while a gas turbine is a combined device of compressor, combustion chamber, and turbine executing a cyclic operation to deliver work as either torque or thrust. A gas turbine, also called a combustion turbine, is a rotary engine that extracts energy from a flow of hot gas produced by combustion of gas or fuel oil in a stream of compressed air.
227 295 923 1620 747 1578 464 99 438 424 655 41 572 701 281 830 732 1418 718 629 1235 1552 236 1469 1102 1145 956 417 1324 1078 516 475 1054 950 677 314